New York-Style Pizza in Southern Shores

If you're searching for great pizza on the Outer Banks, look no further than Cosmo's Pizzeria at The Marketplace in Southern Shores!

Cosmo’s Pizzeria has been serving award winning “New York” style pizza to Outer Banks locals and visitors since 1995. Recognized as a local favorite, Cosmo’s only uses the finest ingredients to prepare the freshest pizza, tastiest pasta dishes and mouth-watering subs on the northern beaches.

Voted 2024 Bronze Winner for the BEST PIZZA in the Reader's Choice BEST of the OBX contest!

Also Serving:
Strombolis
Calzones
Meatballs
Toasted Subs
Chicken Parmesan
Cannolis
Rigatoni Penne
Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Cheesesteaks
Gluten-Free Pasta

Cosmo’s beer list includes a selection of both domestics and imports, and wine is available by the bottle or glass. We also have a selection of fountain sodas and bottled drinks. And if you have a sweet tooth, be sure to try a famous cannoli for dessert!

Grab your crew and satisfy your Outer Banks pizza craving at Cosmo's Pizzeria in Southern Shores, open year-round!

THANK YOU for Voting Us a Winner in the BEST OF OBX Contest!
2024 WINNER

Best Pizza

Southern Shores
Hours
*Off-season hours may vary*
Call 252-261-8388 for current hours.
  • Monday11:00AM-08:30PM
  • Tuesday11:00AM-08:30PM
  • Wednesday11:00AM-08:30PM
  • Thursday11:00AM-08:30PM
  • Friday11:00AM-08:30PM
  • Saturday12:00PM-08:30PM
  • Sunday12:00PM-08:30PM
Categories
Restaurants
Outer Banks Milepost System
Gray's

Gray’s Outer Banks Lifestyle Clothing Company offers the absolute best in Outer Banks T-shirts and Sweatshirts including Champion, Under Armour with "Outer Banks” and Gear! We carry quality fashions and accessories for the whole family by all your favorite brands including Tommy Bahama, Tribal, ESCAPE, Billabong, Quiksilver, Jack O’Neill, RVCA, Olukai, Cobian, Spartina, Scout, Brighton.

 

Whether you’re shopping for apparel, shoes & accessories, gifts & toys or OBX and Big Duck souvenirs, Gray’s offers the best brands and quality for a beach lifestyle at any of our 4 locations! From sportswear to beachwear and everything in between, Gray’s will outfit your entire family. You can also find great beach accessories at Gray’s, such as Costa sunglasses, Olukai sandals and Sun Bum sunscreen and hair products. Be sure to shop Gray’s signature Big Duck found on t-shirts, sweatshirts and gift items!

 

Established in 1948 by Walter and Stelle Gray, Gray’s began as a single store on the beach road in Nags Head, a land mark that has been beautifully transformed into Seagreen Art Gallery. Visitors to the original Gray’s may remember that the family home was located above the store and that Walter Gray had a passion for Big Band music that was often playing on the store speakers, giving shoppers a little swing in their step.

 

Modern-day Gray’s is still family owned and operated by their children Ronnie and Julie Gray, who carry on a legacy of superior customer service and traditional values. Ronnie’s wife Susan is also an important part of the business. “It really was always a family operating as a business rather than a business being run by a family,” explains Ronnie Gray. “When our visitors come in, they are greeted by a warm hello and a ‘Welcome to Gray’s.’ We try to welcome them as if they’re entering our own home”

(More Locations)